Toronto Blue Jays @ New York Yankees

Back to Games
Toronto Blue Jays21-25 (8-14 away)
 Final 6 - 7
New York Yankees28-19 (14-6 home)
2.50Bally Bet ML 1.65BetUS
+1.5 (1.75)DraftKings Spread -1 (1.78)ReBet
O 8.5 (1.77)theScore Bet O/U U 9 (1.93)LowVig.ag

Team Stats

Toronto Blue Jays
New York Yankees
21-25 Record 28-19
W2 Streak L2
4.1 Offence 5.0
4.3 Defence 3.6
8.4 Total 8.6
-0.2 Margin +1.4
23-22-1 Spread 27-19-1
W2 ATS Streak W1
23-23 O/U 21-23-3
U3 O/U Streak O3
Toronto Blue Jays
New York Yankees
8-14 Record 14-6
W2 Streak W1
3.6 Offence 6.6
4.0 Defence 4.2
7.5 Total 10.7
-0.4 Margin +2.4
11-11 Spread 12-8
W2 ATS Streak W1
10-12 O/U 12-7-1
U4 O/U Streak O1
No head-to-head games found

Team Schedule

Date Opponent Result ML Spread O/U
May 17, '26 @ Detroit Tigers W 4-1 W 1.91 W -1 U 7.5
May 16, '26 @ Detroit Tigers W 2-1 W 2.00 W +1.5 U 8
May 15, '26 @ Detroit Tigers L 2-3 L 1.84 L -1 U 7.5
May 13, '26 Tampa Bay Rays W 5-3 W 1.72 W -1 O 7.5
May 12, '26 Tampa Bay Rays L 6-7 L 2.05 W +1.5 O 8
May 11, '26 Tampa Bay Rays L 5-8 L 1.87 L +1.5 O 7
May 10, '26 Los Angeles Angels L 1-6 L 1.92 L +1.5 U 8
May 9, '26 Los Angeles Angels W 14-1 W 1.56 W -1 O 8.5
May 8, '26 Los Angeles Angels W 2-0 W 1.67 W -1 U 7.5
May 6, '26 @ Tampa Bay Rays L 0-3 L 2.18 L +1.5 U 7.5
Date Opponent Result ML Spread O/U
May 17, '26 @ New York Mets L 6-7 L 2.13 W +1.5 O 8.5
May 16, '26 @ New York Mets L 3-6 L 1.85 L -1 O 8.5
May 15, '26 @ New York Mets W 5-2 W 1.71 W -1 O 6.5
May 13, '26 @ Baltimore Orioles L 0-7 L 1.67 L -1.5 U 8.5
May 12, '26 @ Baltimore Orioles W 6-2 W 1.78 W -1 U 8.5
May 11, '26 @ Baltimore Orioles L 2-3 L 1.70 L -1 U 8.5
May 10, '26 @ Milwaukee Brewers L 3-4 L 2.06 W +1.5 U 8
May 9, '26 @ Milwaukee Brewers L 3-4 L 1.79 L -1 U 7.5
May 8, '26 @ Milwaukee Brewers L 0-6 L 1.87 L -1 U 7.5
May 7, '26 Texas Rangers W 9-2 W 1.70 W -1 O 8.5
No head-to-head games found

Best Lines/Odds

Toronto Blue Jays New York Yankees
BestClosing 2.50-0.18Bally Bet 1.65+0.11BetUS
BestOpening 2.68FanDuel 1.54BetOnline.ag
Toronto Blue Jays New York Yankees
BestClosing +1.5(1.75-0.08)DraftKings -1+0.5(1.78-0.32)ReBet
BestOpening +1.5(1.83)Caesars -1.5(2.10)BetMGM
Over Under
BestClosing O 8.5(1.77-0.16)theScore Bet U 9(1.93+0.10)LowVig.ag
BestOpening O 8.5(1.93)LowVig.ag U 9(1.83)Bovada

Odds History

Book Best Odds
Bally Bet Toronto Blue Jays 2.50-0.15
New York Yankees 1.55+0.05
BetMGM Toronto Blue Jays 2.40-0.15
New York Yankees 1.59+0.06
BetOnline.ag Toronto Blue Jays 2.41-0.26
New York Yankees 1.64+0.10
BetRivers Toronto Blue Jays 2.48-0.15
New York Yankees 1.54+0.05
BetUS Toronto Blue Jays 2.38-0.24
New York Yankees 1.65+0.11
Bovada Toronto Blue Jays 2.33-0.33
New York Yankees 1.63+0.13
Caesars Toronto Blue Jays 2.40-0.22
New York Yankees 1.61+0.10
DraftKings Toronto Blue Jays 2.46-0.17
New York Yankees 1.56+0.06
Fanatics Toronto Blue Jays 2.40-0.20
New York Yankees 1.59+0.08
FanDuel Toronto Blue Jays 2.42-0.26
New York Yankees 1.60+0.10
LowVig.ag Toronto Blue Jays 2.41-0.26
New York Yankees 1.64+0.10
MyBookie.ag Toronto Blue Jays 2.41-0.25
New York Yankees 1.60+0.09
ReBet Toronto Blue Jays 2.45-0.05
New York Yankees 1.57+0.10
theScore Bet Toronto Blue Jays 2.45-0.20
New York Yankees 1.59+0.08
Book Best Odds
Bally Bet Toronto Blue Jays +1.5(1.72-0.06)
New York Yankees -1.5(2.14+0.10)
BetMGM Toronto Blue Jays +1.5(1.71-0.03)
New York Yankees -1.5(2.15+0.05)
BetOnline.ag Toronto Blue Jays +1.5(1.73-0.07)
New York Yankees -1.5(2.17+0.12)
BetRivers Toronto Blue Jays +1-0.5(2.05+0.27)
New York Yankees -1+0.5(1.77-0.27)
BetUS Toronto Blue Jays +1.5(1.74-0.06)
New York Yankees -1.5(2.15+0.10)
Bovada Toronto Blue Jays +1.5(1.71-0.09)
New York Yankees -1.5(2.20+0.15)
Caesars Toronto Blue Jays +1.5(1.74-0.09)
New York Yankees -1.5(2.15+0.15)
DraftKings Toronto Blue Jays +1.5(1.75-0.01)
New York Yankees -1.5(2.10+0.01)
Fanatics Toronto Blue Jays +1.5(1.71-0.09)
New York Yankees -1.5(2.15+0.10)
FanDuel Toronto Blue Jays +1.5(1.75-0.08)
New York Yankees -1.5(2.12+0.12)
LowVig.ag Toronto Blue Jays +1.5(1.74-0.08)
New York Yankees -1.5(2.19+0.11)
MyBookie.ag Toronto Blue Jays +1.5(1.70-0.13)
New York Yankees -1.5(2.15+0.16)
ReBet Toronto Blue Jays +1-0.5(2.01+0.22)
New York Yankees -1+0.5(1.78-0.18)
theScore Bet Toronto Blue Jays +1.5(1.69-0.11)
New York Yankees -1.5(2.20+0.15)
Book Best Odds
Bally Bet Over O 9+0.5(1.96+0.15)
Under U 9+0.5(1.85-0.15)
BetMGM Over O 9+0.5(1.95+0.08)
Under U 9+0.5(1.87-0.08)
BetOnline.ag Over O 9+0.5(1.92+0.01)
Under U 9+0.5(1.90-0.01)
BetRivers Over O 9+0.5(1.95+0.14)
Under U 9+0.5(1.85-0.15)
BetUS Over O 9+0.5(1.95+0.08)
Under U 9+0.5(1.87-0.08)
Bovada Over O 9(1.95-0.05)
Under U 9(1.87+0.04)
Caesars Over O 9+0.5(1.95+0.08)
Under U 9+0.5(1.87-0.08)
DraftKings Over O 9+0.5(1.94+0.07)
Under U 9+0.5(1.88-0.07)
Fanatics Over O 9+0.5(1.95+0.04)
Under U 9+0.5(1.87-0.04)
FanDuel Over O 9+0.5(1.95+0.14)
Under U 9+0.5(1.87-0.15)
LowVig.ag Over O 9+0.5(1.94+0.01)
Under U 9+0.5(1.93)
MyBookie.ag Over O 9+0.5(1.93+0.06)
Under U 9+0.5(1.88-0.06)
ReBet Over O 9+0.5(1.92+0.14)
Under U 9+0.5(1.87-0.10)
theScore Bet Over O 8.5(1.77-0.03)
Under U 8.5(2.10+0.05)

Game Results by Top Cappers

Capper Profit Results
#1 highrollerwiseguy +4.00
Over 9@ 2.00for 4 unitsWon +4.00
#2 beardnation +3.88
Over 9@ 1.97for 4 unitsWon +3.88
#3 beardbettor +3.52
Over 8.5@ 1.88for 4 unitsWon +3.52
#4 vigorishscout +3.32
Toronto Blue Jays +1.5@ 1.83for 4 unitsWon +3.32
#5 raghammer +3.24
Over 8.5@ 1.81for 4 unitsWon +3.24
#6 valuehunter +3.20
Toronto Blue Jays +1.5@ 1.80for 4 unitsWon +3.20
#7 totalsniper +2.85
Over 9@ 1.95for 3 unitsWon +2.85
#8 evcrusher +2.84
Toronto Blue Jays +1.5@ 1.71for 4 unitsWon +2.84
#9 proptitan +2.52
New York Yankees@ 1.63for 4 unitsWon +2.52
#10 pickemcontrarian +2.49
Toronto Blue Jays +1.5@ 1.83for 3 unitsWon +2.49
#11 pickhero +2.46
Over 8.5@ 1.82for 3 unitsWon +2.46
#12 arbitragesyndicate +2.43
Toronto Blue Jays +1.5@ 1.81for 3 unitsWon +2.43
#13 covershark +2.43
Over 8.5@ 1.81for 3 unitsWon +2.43
#14 driftbeast +2.40
Toronto Blue Jays +1.5@ 1.80for 3 unitsWon +2.40
#15 nickelpilot +2.36
New York Yankees@ 1.59for 4 unitsWon +2.36
#16 beardplays +2.07
Toronto Blue Jays +1.5@ 1.69for 3 unitsWon +2.07
#17 teaserbeast +1.92
New York Yankees@ 1.48for 4 unitsWon +1.92
#18 fadesyndicate +1.76
Over 8.5@ 1.88for 2 unitsWon +1.76
#19 moneylinebettor +1.71
New York Yankees@ 1.57for 3 unitsWon +1.71
#20 spreadscout +1.70
Toronto Blue Jays +1.5@ 1.85for 2 unitsWon +1.70

Game Consensus

39 picks | 68 units
Toronto Blue Jays
New York Yankees
17 picks | 44%
22 picks | 56%
27 units | 40%
41 units | 60%
Picks Per Odds Range
Toronto Blue Jays
Picks
New York Yankees
2.42 - 2.73
17
22
1.46 - 1.64
46 picks | 93 units
Toronto Blue Jays
New York Yankees
25 picks | 54%
21 picks | 46%
49 units | 53%
44 units | 47%
Picks Per Line
Toronto Blue Jays
Picks
New York Yankees
+1.5
25
21
-1.5
58 picks | 130 units
Over
Under
21 picks | 36%
37 picks | 64%
41 units | 32%
89 units | 68%
Picks Per Line
Over
Picks
Under
O 8.5
16
22
U 8.5
O 9
5
15
U 9

Moneyline

Trends for best moneyline odds.

Toronto Blue Jays (2.50)

  • Toronto Blue Jays won 2 straight Streak
  • Toronto Blue Jays won 2 straight on the road Streak - Away
  • New York Yankees lost 2 straight Streak
  • Toronto Blue Jays moneyline shortened by -0.18 from 2.68 to 2.50 Closing line movement

New York Yankees (1.65)

  • New York Yankees won as strong favorite in 9 of 11 (82%) Strong favorite split
  • New York Yankees won as home favorite in 14 of 20 (70%) Favorite split - Home
  • Toronto Blue Jays lost as underdog in 12 of 17 (71%) Underdog split
  • New York Yankees won at home in 14 of 20 (70%) Season - Home
  • Toronto Blue Jays lost as away underdog in 8 of 12 (67%) Underdog split - Away
  • Toronto Blue Jays lost on the road in 14 of 22 (64%) Season - Away
  • New York Yankees won as favorite in 26 of 43 (60%) Favorite split
  • New York Yankees won 28 of 47 (60%) Season
  • Toronto Blue Jays lost 25 of 46 (54%) Season

Spread

Trends for best spread lines.

Toronto Blue Jays +1.5

  • Toronto Blue Jays covered +1.5 in 5 straight Streak
  • Toronto Blue Jays covered +1.5 on the road in 14 of 22 (64%) Season at current line - Away
  • Toronto Blue Jays covered +1.5 in 29 of 46 (63%) Season at current line
  • Toronto Blue Jays covered +1.5 in 3 straight on the road Streak - Away
  • New York Yankees failed to cover -1.5 in 2 straight Streak

New York Yankees -1

  • New York Yankees covered as strong favorite in 9 of 11 (82%) Strong favorite ATS split
  • Toronto Blue Jays failed to cover as away underdog in 6 of 7 (86%) Underdog ATS split - Away
  • Toronto Blue Jays failed to cover as underdog in 10 of 15 (67%) Underdog ATS split
  • New York Yankees covered as home favorite in 12 of 20 (60%) Favorite ATS split - Home
  • New York Yankees covered -1 at home in 12 of 20 (60%) Season at current line - Home
  • New York Yankees covered as favorite in 24 of 45 (53%) Favorite ATS split
  • New York Yankees covered -1 in 25 of 47 (53%) Season at current line

Total

Trends for best over/under lines.

Over 8.5

  • New York Yankees played over 8.5 at home in 13 of 20 (65%) Season at current total
  • New York Yankees played over 8.5 in 2 straight Streak

Under 9

  • Toronto Blue Jays played under 9 on the road in 14 of 19 (74%) Season at current total
  • Toronto Blue Jays played under 9 in 7 straight on the road Streak - Away
  • Toronto Blue Jays played under 9 in 27 of 42 (64%) Season at current total
  • New York Yankees played under 9 in 27 of 42 (64%) Season at current total
  • Both teams played under 9 in 54 of 84 (64%) Season at current total - Both teams
  • Toronto Blue Jays played under 9 in 4 straight Streak